ECOSOC Dialogue: a federal structure for the UN Development System?

ECOSOC Dialogue: a federal structure for the UN Development System?

Download PDF 2.3 MB

Baumann, Max-Otto
Briefing Paper 1/2016

Bonn: German Development Institute / Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE)

Dt. Ausg. u.d.T.:
ECOSOC-Dialog: eine föderale Struktur für das VN-Entwicklungssystem?
(Analysen und Stellungnahmen 15/2015)

The 2030 Agenda, with its 17 Sustainable Development Goals, adds new urgency to the reform of the UN Development System (UNDS). If we wish the UNDS to play a decisive role in sustainable development, it must be made fit for purpose. UN member states have recognized the need for action. In December 2014, they launched a state dialogue in the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) in order to discuss the longer-term positioning of the UNDS and present concrete reform proposals by mid-2016. To date, no breakthrough has been achieved. Participating states are opting for incremental reforms within existing mandates and structures, which are unlikely to bring the necessary changes.
The general restraint on tackling ambitious reforms stands in contrast to the current comparatively favourable context for repositioning the UNDS. The 2030 Agenda, adopted successfully last September at the greatest ever UN summit so far, requires a revamp of the UNDS so that it can effectively and efficiently assist member states in implementing both their own and collective development interests. The increased awareness of global problems associated with globalisation and climate change has led to calls to give the UNDS better global problem-solving capacities. Additionally, it is by no means only OECD states that are deploring the fragmentation and incoherence of the UNDS.
The second phase of the ECOSOC Dialogue now provides an opportunity to take the necessary steps towards an ambitious UNDS reform. Emphasis should be placed on a more comprehensive reform package. The present paper proposes a federal structure for the UNDS, based on two elements: (1) a strengthening of the central, system-wide governance capacity, while (2) largely maintaining the subsidiary independence of the UN agencies.
Significant elements of a federally structured UNDS are as follows:

  • Reinforcement of the ECOSOC as a forum for the intergovernmental, system-wide governance of the UNDS, and creation of a corresponding administrative entity of equal weight ("Development Commission");

  • Expansion of existing system-wide funding mechanisms based on voluntary contributions, and the introduction of a new component of assessed contributions;

  • Retention of the far-reaching subsidiary independence of the funds, programmes and specialised agencies, but on the basis of a review of their mandates;

  • Reform of governance structures, including a geographically fair distribution of seats and the representation of various stakeholder groups.

Although these reforms are ambitious, they may well meet with political acceptance from a large majority of states. It is now time to overcome the formation of rival North and South camps, and to focus on common interests via an open, inclusive and constructive dialogue.

Über den Autor

Baumann, Max-Otto

Politikwissenschaftler

Max-Otto Baumann

Weitere Expertinnen/Experten zu diesem Thema

Bauer, Steffen

Politikwissenschaftler 

Blankenbach, Johannes

Politikwissenschaftler 

Brandi, Clara

Ökonomin und Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Hackenesch, Christine

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Janus, Heiner

Politikwissenschaftler 

Keijzer, Niels

Sozialwissenschaftler 

Koch, Svea

Sozialwissenschaftlerin 

Loewe, Markus

Volkswirt 

Mahn Jones, Timo Casjen

Politikwissenschaftler 

Richerzhagen, Carmen

Agrar- und Umweltökonomin 

Rippin, Nicole

Ökonomin 

Scholz, Imme

Soziologin 

Weinlich, Silke

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Mathis, Okka Lou

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Henökl, Thomas

Politikwissenschaftler 

Hilbrich, Sören

Ökonom 

Schwachula, Anna

Soziologin 

Aktuelle Publikationen

The relevance of legitimation – a new framework for analysis

von Haldenwang, Christian
Externe Publikationen, 23.03.2017

Localising sovereign debt: the rise of local currency bond markets in Sub-Saharan Africa

Dafe, Florence / Dennis Essers / Ulrich Volz
Externe Publikationen, 23.03.2017

Brexit und die EU-Außenpolitik: Das Europäische Erbe Großbritanniens

Henökl, Thomas
Die aktuelle Kolumne, 16.03.2017

Accountability for development cooperation under the 2030 Agenda

Mahn Jones, Timo Casjen
Discussion Paper 10/2017