Identifying future growth potentials: a consolidated approach

Identifying future growth potentials: a consolidated approach

Download PDF 1.2 MB

Altenburg, Tilman / Wilfried Lütkenhorst
Briefing Paper 15/2017

Bonn: German Development Institute / Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE)

When Alice in Wonderland wonders which way she should take, the Cheshire Cat responds that it depends on where she wants to go! Researchers and policy-makers considering a country’s long-term development path also have to know where they want to go. Typically, they seek to determine the realistic growth potentials for a country’s economy and how to reach them, and identify the key assets that could make the country competitive and the economic sectors that should be prioritised to drive structural change. Most critically, they have to find out how to reconcile narrow goals regarding com­petitive­ness and productivity with broader goals related to social inclusive­ness and environmental sustainability.

The challenge is to design a methodology for evidence-based anticipation of future competitive advantages that merit industrial policy measures. The sectors that could create viable growth must be understood. Identifying a country’s competitive advantage in five to 10 years presents a thorny methodological challenge and a complex set of factors to consider, including: avail­able domestic resources, institutional capabilities, production costs relative to other countries, geographic conditions, the country’s position within the global trade and investment system (including expected changes in relevant regulatory regimes), and also long-term shifts towards new technological domains. More often than not, the analytical, conceptual and institutional preconditions for such an exercise exceed the capabilities of developing countries and constitute a core area of advisory services provided by develop­ment cooperation partners.

Against this backdrop, we explore three aspects of possible methodologies:

1.   The strengths and weaknesses of various contempo­rary methodologies, all of which fail to include im­portant determinants of future competitive ad­van­tages. Since they do shed light on various comple­men­tary aspects, however, we suggest combining them to create a more complete picture of emerging opportunities.

2.   The growing role of disruptive structural change. We are already confronted with radical and rapid structural change that impacts virtually all economic sectors and disrupts the prevailing techno-economic trajectory (seemingly the case for both decarboni­sation and digitalisation). What are the method­logical implica­tions for predicting future competitive advantages? We recommend a stronger emphasis on using ‘open’ qualitative forecasting methods.

3.   Evidence-based approaches for measuring compete­tiveness and anticipating its future direction must be embedded into a political economy framework that connects analytical tools to societal objectives and accounts for the different imple­mentation capabilities of various countries.

Essentially, we argue that there is no ‘silver bullet’ method­o­logy for predicting emerging patterns of competitiveness. However, a variety of tools can be used to reduce the number of promising options and inform policy-makers about how to exploit emerging opportunities.

Über den Autor

Altenburg, Tilman

Wirtschaftsgeograph

Tilman Altenburg

Weitere Expertinnen/Experten zu diesem Thema

Breuer, Anita

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Brüntrup, Michael

Agrarökonom 

Burchi, Francesco

Entwicklungsökonom 

Herrmann, Raoul

Ökonom 

Negre, Mario

Ökonom 

Rippin, Nicole

Ökonomin 

Dick, Eva

Soziologin und Raumplanerin 

Schwachula, Anna

Soziologin 

Malerba, Daniele

Ökonom 

Aktuelle Publikationen

COP23 - Die Augen der Welt sind auf Bonn gerichtet

Bauer, Steffen / Clara Brandi
Externe Publikationen, 23.10.2017

Akteure des Südens beginnen mit der Gestaltung von Nachhaltigkeitsstandards

Fues, Thomas / Sven Grimm
Die aktuelle Kolumne, 23.10.2017

COP23 – The eyes of the world are on Bonn

Bauer, Steffen / Clara Brandi
Externe Publikationen, 21.10.2017

Deutschlands Rolle für globale Entwicklung: der Anfang einer Strategiedebatte

Klingebiel, Stephan
Mitarbeiter sonstige, 18.10.2017

China’s 19th Party Congress: A stronger role for China in global development?

Janus, Heiner / Lixia Tang
Die aktuelle Kolumne, 17.10.2017