Supporting or thwarting? The influence of EU migration policies on African free movement regimes in West and North-eastern Africa

Supporting or thwarting? The influence of EU migration policies on African free movement regimes in West and North-eastern Africa

Download PDF 1,41 MB

Castillejo, Clare / Eva Dick / Benjamin Schraven
Briefing Paper 18/2019

Bonn: German Development Institute / Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE)

DOI: 10.23661/bp18.2019

The European Union (EU) approach to migration in Africa has significantly shifted in the last few years. Notably since 2015, it has focused on preventing irregular migration and privileges engagement with the main countries of origin and transit of migrants. In the context of the 2015 Joint Valletta Action Plan (JVAP), a funding instrument – the EU Emergency Trust Fund for Africa (EUTF) –was created to channel development aid in support of EU interests in curbing migration.
As reflected in historical and more recent policy agendas, economic integration and free movement within the continent and its regions constitute key elements of African development ambitions and narratives. But an increasing body of research suggests that EU activities (in particular the EUTF) sideline or even undermine African stakeholders and interests in decision-making and programming on migration.
This paper analyses the effects of EU political dialogue and programming on regional free movement (RFM) in two African regions: the Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD) in the Horn of Africa and the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) in West Africa. These regions receive the greatest amount of EUTF funding. While both IGAD and ECOWAS have frameworks on RFM, these are at very different stages of development.
The analysis, based on literature review and field research, shows that EU approaches to and impact on RFM differ significantly in the two regions. In the IGAD region, the EU is not undermining but rather supporting free movement – albeit not as significantly as it could. In contrast, in the ECOWAS region the EU’s focus on preventing irregular migration is undermining progress on RFM.
At least three factors drive this difference: 1) institutional coherence and decision-making powers vary considerably in the two regions; 2) whereas some powerful member states in the IGAD region consider free movement to be a barrier to their hegemonic role, member states in the ECOWAS region largely see it as positive; and 3) EU migration programming in these regions is driven by different levels of urgency – with the largest number of irregular migrants coming from West Africa, the EU’s objective of curbing migration is more accentuated in the ECOWAS region.
A number of policy processes between and within the EU and Africa are currently underway that could reshape how the EU engages with Africa on migration issues, provided existing tensions are acknowledged and addressed. Since RFM is in the long-term interests of both parties, given its potential value to contribute to growth, development and stability within Africa, the EU should pursue the following programmatic steps for its support:

  • Supporting regional organisations. This includes tailored capacity support in strategic direction, analytical capacity and outreach to member states. This should build on lessons from existing EU projects in support of RFM.

  • Enhancing coherence between security and development. This means for example that existing programmes addressing irregular migration are examined regarding their impact on free movement.
  • Improving capacity of EU delegations. This requires linking the regional EU delegations more effectively to EU delegations in member states to support joint regional and national level actions on RFM.

Über die Autoren

Castillejo, Clare

Politikwissenschaftlerin

Dick, Eva

Soziologin und Raumplanerin

Dick

Schraven, Benjamin

Politikwissenschaftler

Schraven

Weitere Expertinnen/Experten zu diesem Thema

Baumann, Max-Otto

Politikwissenschaftler 

Bergmann, Julian

Politikwissenschaftler 

Burni, Aline

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Erforth, Benedikt

Politikwissenschaftler 

Grävingholt, Jörn

Politikwissenschaftler 

Hackenesch, Christine

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Högl, Maximilian

Politikwissenschaftler 

Janus, Heiner

Politikwissenschaftler 

Kaplan, Lennart

Wirtschaftswissenschaftler 

Keijzer, Niels

Sozialwissenschaftler 

Kloke-Lesch, Adolf

Stadt- und Regionalplaner 

Koch, Svea

Sozialwissenschaftlerin 

Kuhnt, Jana

Entwicklungsökonomin 

Marschall, Paul

Ökonom 

Martin-Shields, Charles

Politikwissenschaftler 

Oehler, Hannes

Ökonom 

Olekseyuk, Zoryana

Ökonomin 

Sturm, Janina

Ökonomin und Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Trautner, Bernhard

Politikwissenschaftler 

Weinlich, Silke

Politikwissenschaftlerin