Promoting policy coherence within the 2030 Agenda framework: externalities, trade-offs and politics

Brand, Alexander / Mark Furness / Niels Keijzer
External Publications (2021)

in: Politics and Governance 9 (1), 108 - 118

DOI: 10.17645/pag.v9i1.3608
Open access

The promotion of Policy Coherence for Sustainable Development is one of the 169 targets of the 2030 Agenda, and considered a key means of implementation. The 2030 Agenda, while noble and necessary to put humanity on a sustainable path, has vastly exacerbated the complexity and ambiguity of development policymaking. This article challenges two assumptions that are common in both policy discussions and associated scholarly debates: First, the technocratic belief that policy coherence is an authentically attainable objective; and second, whether efforts to improve the coherence within and across policies makes achieving the Sustainable Development Goals more likely. We unpack the conventional ‘win-win’ understanding of the policy coherence concept to illustrate that fundamentally incompatible political interests continue to shape global development, and that these cannot be managed away. We argue that heuristic, problem-driven frameworks are needed to promote coherence in settings where these fundamental inconsistencies are likely to persist. Instead of mapping synergies ex-ante, future research and policy debates should focus on navigating political trade-offs and hierarchies while confronting the longer-term goal conflicts that reproduce unsustainable policy choices.

About the authors

Furness, Mark

Political Science

Furness

Keijzer, Niels

Social Science

Keijzer

Further experts

Bauer, Steffen

Political scientist 

Baumann, Max-Otto

Political Science 

Baye, Richmond

Economy 

Bergmann, Julian

Political Science 

Brandi, Clara

Economy and Political Science 

Brehm, Johannes

Economy 

Burni, Aline

Political Science 

Droste, Leonie Marie

Political Science 

Erforth, Benedikt

Political Science 

Esser, Daniel

Development Studies, Human Geography 

Friesen, Ina

Political Science 

Grimm, Sven

Political Science 

Gronen, Maria Elisabeth

Social Science 

Götze, Jacqueline

Political Scientist 

Hackenesch, Christine

Political Science 

Hilbrich, Sören

Economy 

Hägele, Ramona

Political Scientist 

Iacobuta, Gabriela

Environmental Researcher 

Janus, Heiner

Political Science 

Kloke-Lesch, Adolf

Urban and regional planning 

Koch, Svea

Social Science 

Laudage, Sabine

Economy 

Marschall, Paul

Economy 

Mathis, Okka Lou

Political Scientist 

Scholtes, Fabian

Economist 

Scholz, Imme

Sociologist 

Schulz, Sabrina

Political Science 

Schwachula, Anna

Sociology 

Srigiri, Srinivasa Reddy

Agricultural Economist 

Vogel, Johanna

International Cultural Economy 

Wehrmann, Dorothea

Sociology 

Weinlich, Silke

Political Science