The democratic deficit of the G20

Hilbrich, Sören
External Publications (2021)

in: Journal of Global Ethics, first published 10.10.2021

DOI: 10.1080/17449626.2021.1969982
Open access

In the last few decades, the democratic credentials of global governance institutions have been extensively debated in the fields of international relations and political philosophy. However, despite their prominent role in the architecture of global governance, club governance institutions like the Group of Seven (G7) or the Group of Twenty (G20) have rarely been considered from the perspective of democratic theory. Focussing on the G20, this paper analyses its functions in international political practice and discusses whether, in exercising these functions, the G20 exhibits a democratic deficit. As a standard of democracy, the analysis uses the all-affected principle, according to which all those who are affected by a policy decision should be given the opportunity to participate in decision-making. This paper identifies several democratic shortcomings of the G20, for instance related to the exclusion of citizens of non-member states and a lack of parliamentary and public control. By describing realisable reforms that could to some degree alleviate these shortcomings, it is shown that more democratic institutional alternatives are feasible. Thus, the ascription of a democratic deficit to the G20 is warranted.

About the author

Hilbrich

Further experts

Breuer, Anita

Political Scientist 

Burni, Aline

Political Science 

Fiedler, Charlotte

Political Scientist 

Grävingholt, Jörn

Political Scientist 

Hadank-Rauch, Rebecca

Environmental and Development Sciences 

Haug, Sebastian

Political Science 

Leininger, Julia

Political Scientist 

Mehl, Regine

Political Science 

Morare, Ditebogo Modiegi

Political Science 

Mross, Karina

Political Scientist 

Nowack, Daniel

Political Scientist 

Olekseyuk, Zoryana

Economist 

Stewart, Benjamin

Social Science 

Sudermann, Yannick

Human Geography and Political Science 

Volz, Ulrich

Economist 

Wehrmann, Dorothea

Sociology 

Wingens, Christopher

Political Scientiest 

Ziaja, Sebastian

Political Scientist