To regulate or not to regulate? Jordan’s approach to digital ride-hailing platform Careem

Zintl, Tina
External Publications (2022)

in: Labor and Politics in the Middle East and North Africa (POMEPS Studies 45), 76-81

Volltext/Full text

Digitalization is a disruptive megatrend which cannot be stopped but needs to be steered and used. Just how regulators should respond to it is less clear. For instance, Jordanian authorities faced the boom of the ride-hailing platform Careem, now an Uber subsidiary, in Jordan’s capital Amman. They were forced to choose between licensing Careem, and thus allowing flexible yet informal job creation, or protecting the entrenched taxi businesses. Against the backdrop of Jordan’s dire economic situation and rampant unemployment figures, regulators decided for a middle way, licensing ride-hailing platforms, yet limiting their growth and confining them to an upmarket line of business. As this paper demonstrates, this approach created new fractions and insider-outsider dynamics on the labour market.
The paper draws on interviews with Careem and taxi drivers, as well as expert interviews with staff and customers in 2019 to show (i) how Careem drivers’ employment situation allowed for comparatively high income opportunities but exposed them to considerable financial risks also due to obligatory car ownership, and (ii) how regulators’ differentiated approach created fairer competition but also led to labour market segmentation by distorting wage levels and incentives for the highly-skilled, who also experience de-skilling while working outside their professional field. Vulnerabilities and precarious working conditions were further exposed during the Covid-19 lockdowns.

About the author

Zintl, Tina

Political Scientist

Zintl

Further experts

Altenburg, Tilman

Economic Geography 

Asimeng, Emmanuel Theodore

Urban Planning, Sustainability 

Breuer, Anita

Political Scientist 

Eberz, Isabelle

Cultural Science 

El-Haddad, Amirah

Economy 

Kachelmann, Matthias

Political Science 

Loewe, Markus

Economy 

Sommer, Christoph

Economist 

Sowa, Alina

Economics 

Stewart, Benjamin

Social Science 

Strohmaier, Rita

Economy 

Stöcker, Alexander

Economics 

Tamasiga, Phemelo

Economics 

Vogel, Tim

Economy 

Vrolijk, Kasper

Economy 

Wisskirchen, Alma

Political Science