Towards a democratic yardstick? Evaluations of international institutions in academic textbooks, 1970-2010

Dingwerth, Klaus / Ina Lehmann / Ellen Reichel / Tobias Weise
Externe Publikationen (2011)

New York: New York Univ. School of Law (Jean Monnet Working Paper 14/2011)

Volltext/Document

This paper has two aims. First, we examine how relevant democracy is as a normative standard in academic textbook evaluations of international institutions and how the relevance of democracy-based evaluations has changed over time. Second, we are interested in what ‘democracy’ means when it is used in textbook evaluations of international institutions, and how the meaning of the term democracy in such evaluations has changed over time. An analysis of seventy-one academic textbooks on international security, environmental, and human rights politics leads us to several answers. Numerically, democracy is only one normative standard among others, and it does not seem to become more central in more recent decades. Qualitatively, we can observe slight changes in relation to three aspects. First, the range of legitimacy-relevant actors expands over time, most notably in relation to non-state actors as legitimate participants in (or even subjects of) international policy-making. Second, representational concerns become more relevant in justifying demands for greater participation in international institutions. Third, international organizations are increasingly discussed not only as subjects that enhance the transparency and accountability of the policies of their member states, but also as the objects of legitimate demands for transparency and accountability themselves.

Über den Autor

Lehmann, Ina

Politikwissenschaftlerin

Weitere Expert*innen zu diesem Thema

Burni, Aline

Politikwissenschaft 

Fiedler, Charlotte

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Hackenesch, Christine

Politikwissenschaft 

Leininger, Julia

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Mross, Karina

Politikwissenschaftlerin 

Nowack, Daniel

Politikwissenschaftler 

Ziaja, Sebastian

Politikwissenschaftler