Environmental provisions in trade agreements: promises at the trade and environment interface

Environmental provisions in trade agreements: promises at the trade and environment interface

Download PDF 1.3 MB

Berger, Axel / Clara Brandi / Dominique Bruhn
Briefing Paper 16/2017

Bonn: German Development Institute / Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE)

Until recently, environmental concerns have played only a marginal role in trade policy. The rulebook of the World Trade Organization (WTO) rarely touches upon environ­men­tal concerns and mainly features an exception clause for the protection of the environment (GATT, Art. XX). How­ever, the rising number of modern preferential trade agree­ments (PTAs) covers an ever-broader array of policy areas, going far beyond the traditional reduction of tariffs by also including environmental provisions. Numerous PTAs nego­tiated on a bilateral and regional basis have compre­hen­sive “green” components. For example, many PTAs include ob­li­ga­tions not to lower environmental standards, the right to regu­late for the benefit of the environment, and the com­mit­ment to implement multilateral environmental agreements.

The inclusion of environmental provisions can spark con­troversies. For some, the inclusion of environmental pro­visions offers untapped potential for actual environ­mental protection, making these agreements more compatible with environment and climate policies. However, trade critics often see these provisions as mere “fig leafs” that are included in modern PTAs in order to make them less controversial in the eyes of the public and legislators. For other critics, they represent an instrument of “green protectionism” in order to keep cheaper products from developing countries out of the market.

Given the newness of the widespread inclusion of environmental provisions in PTAs and the heated debate that is raging about the nature and effects of trade policies, better data and research is needed to understand and analyse this development.

Firstly, we need to improve our understanding of the specific design of these new rules and the related policy initiatives of PTA signatories. What drives the inclusion of environmental provisions in trade agreements? Which are the most innovative agreements and which the most innovative countries in terms of including environmental provisions in PTAs? Which environmental provisions are diffused more often than others into subsequent PTAs?

Secondly, there is a need to understand the interplay between PTAs and other environmental or climate agree­ments. To what extent do PTAs with environmental pro­visions serve the purpose of multilateral environmental agree­ments (MEAs) or the Paris Agreement on climate change?

Last but not the least: What are the implications of environmental provisions? Does the inclusion of these provisions in PTAs help the contracting parties to implement domestic environmental laws?

The innovative and interactive online tool TREND analytics based on the Trade & Environment Database (TREND), which tracks almost 300 different environmental provisions in the texts of about 630 PTAs, offers new ways of going further and of undertaking research to generate fine-grained information on the interplay between trade and the environment, providing fresh insights into a number of relevant policy discussions. This Briefing Paper summarises recent research results based on TREND, along with providing new insights into these questions and policy discussions at the interface of international trade and the environment.

About the authors

Berger, Axel

Political Scientist

Axel Berger

Brandi, Clara

Economist and Political Scientist

Clara Brandi

Bruhn, Dominique

Economist

Dominique Bruhn

Further experts

Altenburg, Tilman

Economic Geographer 

Bauer, Steffen

Political scientist 

Hein, Jonas

Geographer 

Horstmann, Britta

Geographer 

Lindenberg, Nannette

Economist 

Messner, Dirk

Political Scientist 

Never, Babette

Political Scientist 

Pauw, Pieter

Environment Scientist 

Pegels, Anna

Economist 

Schwab, Jakob

Economist 

Current Publications

COP23 - Die Augen der Welt sind auf Bonn gerichtet

Bauer, Steffen / Clara Brandi
Externe Publikationen of 23 October 2017

Southern powers begin shaping sustainability standards

Fues, Thomas / Sven Grimm
The Current Column of 23 October 2017

COP23 – The eyes of the world are on Bonn

Bauer, Steffen / Clara Brandi
Externe Publikationen of 21 October 2017

Deutschlands Rolle für globale Entwicklung: der Anfang einer Strategiedebatte

Klingebiel, Stephan
Mitarbeiter sonstige of 18 October 2017

China’s 19th Party Congress: A stronger role for China in global development?

Janus, Heiner / Lixia Tang
The Current Column of 17 October 2017