Club governance and legitimacy: the perspective of old and rising powers on the G7 and the G20

Brandi, Clara
External Publications (2019)

in: South African Journal of International Affairs 26 (4), 685-702

DOI: 10.1080/10220461.2019.1697354

Club governance is among the most contested of global governance approaches. This article investigates legitimacy evaluations of two informal governance clubs from the perspective of both old powers and rising powers. It examines how legitimate the G7/G8 and the G20 are perceived to be and which (de-)legitimation criteria are used in the context of these summit regimes, assessing how legitimacy evaluations in the media vary across these two settings, across different types of actors and over time. The article shows that rising powers challenge certain aspects of the global order more than old powers. While the criteria linked to output legitimacy, such as effectiveness, tend to be more prominent than criteria on input legitimacy, such as participation, the latter seem to be more important for rising powers than for old powers. This article contributes to the various bodies of literature on club governance, the legitimacy of international institutions and the role of rising powers in global governance.

About the author

Brandi, Clara

Economy and Political Science


Further experts

Baumann, Max-Otto

Political Science 

Berger, Axel

Political Science 

Dafe, Florence

Social Scientist 

Eberz, Isabelle

Cultural Science 

Fiselier, Evelien


Grimm, Sven

Political Science 

Hackenesch, Christine

Political Science 

Haug, Sebastian

Political Science 

Janus, Heiner

Political Science 

Klingebiel, Stephan

Political Science 

Pegels, Anna


Reiners, Wulf

Political Science 

Weinlich, Silke

Political Science